The inspiration for this article comes from one of our trainee life coaches who posted a question on our Forum about how to deal with a client of his who was struggling to make changes in her life … and who claimed to be suffering from a mental illness.
Let me say, right at the outset, that New Insights strongly discourages its certified and trainee life coaches from coaching people with mental illnesses unless they do so under the guidance of a qualified mental health professional.
Nonetheless, in this case I detected some strong clues that mental illness was not an issue (although it is clear that such a condition that had been diagnosed and treated many years ago); rather the issue was one of \’convenient self-labelling\’.
[box type=\”shadow\”]“You may affix a label of convenience to yourself today only to find it won’t come unstuck tomorrow.”
– Yours truly[/box]
Self-labelling (continued)
A handy excuse
Research the term ‘self-labelling’ and you may wish you hadn’t as it is quite a complex field in human psychology and ‘self-labelling theory’ is often referred to in relation to psychiatric conditions and deviant behaviour.
When I refer to self-labelling here, I use the term in connection with mentally well people who use labelling, not in order to acknowledge some condition they may have and are dealing with (which is an admirable quality), but rather as a handy excuse for not taking actions required to bring about the changes they desire at a deeper level.
The labels they apply to themselves may have emanated from some previous diagnosis that no longer affects their ability to change, may have been assimilated from labels that they have heard their parents or other people apply to them, or may be entirely made up.
Some examples
Here are a few examples:
“I am a procrastinator”
“I am a hoarder”
“I am ADD/ADHD”
“I am manic depressive”
“I am an introvert”
“I am an extrovert”
“I am a comfort eater”
“I am bi-polar”
“I am a couch potato”
“I am a loner”
“I am depressed”
“I am a social outcast”
“I am a womaniser”
“I am a controlling type”
In life coaching, we frequently come across clients who use labels as a means to excuse their own self-defeating behaviour.
Wearing a label
By ‘wearing a label\’ the client gains access to a convenient and easy way out of having to take what can seem like difficult action to bring about change in his or her life.
I’m sure you’ve heard the likes of this before:
“You don’t understand, I am a chronic worrier. If I leave my children and go on holiday I might suffer a breakdown.”
“I am an attention span deficit sufferer, there’s no way I could study for a new qualification.”
“My hypertension would never allow me to exercise like that.”
“I am sleep deprived. I have to get to bed very early in the evening, so working in the evenings is out of the question”.
Self-labelling, without any real medical or psychological justification, is often done in order to attract attention and/or pity and to create a focal point for social conversation that makes the individual feel more needed.
When self-labelling becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy
Self-labelling can also become a self-fulfilling prophesy. When someone becomes so used to hiding behind a label, they can actually become that label! What was a convenient excuse can become a genuine excuse … and a serious problem at the same time.
Bringing the issue into conscious awareness
In life coaching, the key to helping someone overcome the inertia that they create through self-labelling and the excuses that go with it, is to bring what is, in effect self-deceit, into their conscious awareness.
By this I mean get them to identify and verbalise the short-term payoff that they are getting from self-labelling and then contrast this with the long-term damage that they are doing to their ability to live the life they (deep down) really want.
Sometimes helping people to move forward requires opening their eyes to their own lies!
[box type=\”shadow\”]
This is the official Blog for New Insights Life Coach Training.
Find out more about life coaching and becoming a life coach here:
SA/Africa: http://www.life-coach-training-sa.com
UK/Europe: http://www.life-coach-training-uk.com
[/box]
I am a master students from Beijing Normal University and I am aiming to conduct a paper on this self-labeling. I also looking for good questionnaires and more concept explanation for self-labeling. I hope you all can help me with my email.
Hi Peter,
All I can offer you is the content of this post. I am sure you will find a great deal more on the Internet.
Good luck with your studies. My own son is currently resident in Beijing too 🙂
I hear it all the time Bill during the course of my work.
Comment such as .”My anxiety is bad I can’d do that.” then they manage to go to the pub, or “I’m bi polar so that makes me say things out of context”
Its easy to spot the ones who use this as an excuse.
For the record I had depression and anxiety and I made it into a positive by turning my own life round to help others as a New Insights trained Life coach.
Well done to you Annette. The conditions referred to are, of course, horrible when they genuinely afflict you. Your response was something to be very proud of!
thanks bill,
this is so true. I notice this behaviour in my life too. its so subtle and it easily resides uniticed. I will be on the watch it for self labels in my life going forward.
The thing is to have an awareness of it as it can easily become an ‘unconscious’ habit!
Thank you Bill.. Great to put this out there for more people to understand what we bring over ourselves… I do appreciate your articles and input often!!
You’re welcome Rika!
Hi Bill, thanks for a brilliant piece. Very well explained and very useful. I hear these self proclaiming prophecies so often. Your blog has deepened my understanding and given me greater insight to deal with it effectively.
Regards
Henry
Nice to see you on the Blog Henry. I’m glad this could be helpful to you 🙂
” but rather as a handy excuse for not taking actions required to bring about the changes they desire at a deeper level. ” This says a lot more than stated. This is truly thought proving.
Thank you Bill, brilliant once again
Thanks for your thoughts Lenny. Always appreciated!
Thanks for an insightful piece, Bill. I can personally identify with this. Indeed very liberating.
🙂
This is great stuff Bill. Our behaviour is a function of our thoughts. Self labelling limits a person from pursuing goals that would lead to personal development and fulfilment. I have seen how clients who hold a negative view about themselves find it difficult to attain higher goals. Thanks for such enlightment.
I’m pleased you enjoyed it!
Hi Bill, I have learnt a lot from your posts. It is interesting to see how careless thoughts and talks can turn into something so limiting. This one in particular is a big example of how we can be our greatest enemy. These posts are so liberating.
Yes, thank you Chika. Not only does our biggest power lie within but our biggest threat too!
Thank you for this amazing post. I have been looking forward to a new post from you for days already and this one truly did not disappoint.
One of my favorite moments during coaching is when my clients have a shift in perspective and are able to overcome their limiting believes. 🙂
I agree Gesche – it is SO fulfilling!
Excellent point Bill and easy to fall into as Ileana said. It can be quite tricky to work with in coaching as those kinds of self-beliefs are often strongly defended. That has been my experience, at least and the difficulty is how to get the client to see that what feels like a ‘friend’ is actually a ‘foe’.
Thanks Tania.
As a coach member, you might like to look at the strategy suggested on the Forum:
http://forum.life-coach-training-sa.com/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=418
A highly appropriate topic, Bill, with which, if we’re truly honest with ourselves, all of us can identify. You give a clear explanation about the origin of such a debilitating habit, and an inspiring way in which it may be transformed to move us forward in the direction of our true potential.
🙂 🙂
Really insightful post, thanks Bill.
So often we fight the labels others impose on us, but are only too happy to fall into the self-labelling trap.
Thanks Ileana